Article Directories – A real life comparison
I’ve been using articles for a while now to generated more free traffic to my websites. Initially I subscribed to an article submission service, where your article is quickly distributed to hundreds of article directories. The theory being that the more places feature the article, the more people will read it and click through to your website. This worked great for the first couple of weeks and then traffic just came to an abrupt halt. I think it basically came down to duplicated content, as one article was distributed to hundreds of sites.
I canceled my subscription, and decided that in the future I’ll do manual submissions. And I’ll only submit 1 article to at most 2 article directories. But which article directories?
A quick search on Google, gave me about 4 directories that I’d like to try. One of them, EzineArticles, I have been using for quite some time already and have had great success. With one article having had +/- 82,000 reads in 4 months with a click through rate of 43%.
My plan to test these article directories were simple. First I’ll upload a few articles onto each directory under the same category. It’s pointless trying to test how good articles work in the different directories if you load articles about English Bull Terriers in one directory and articles about Karma Sutra Positions in another. The reason for this is that the amount of people search for English Bull Terriers will differ from the amount of people searching for Karma Sutra Positions. I will then note how much time it takes for an article to get approved, if the article directory uses an approval system, and what the submission process was like. The main thing I’m looking for is something that goes quickly and effortlessly. Then I’ll wait 1 week and see how many times each article was viewed and how much traffic each article generated for my website. A week is perhaps not a long enough time, but it will give you a fairly good indication.
Based on those 3 steps, I think I’ll have a pretty accurate idea of which article directories I should spend more time on.
So, using a freelancer from RentACoder, I had 10 articles written for my website about Karma Sutra Positions.
Ezinearticles – http://www.ezinearticles.com/
This is probably one of the old article directories out there. They started in 1999 according to their About Us page. I have been using EzineArticles for quite a while, so my expectations are that this will outperform the rest.
Articles Uploaded:
http://ezinearticles.com/?Kama-Sutra-Postions—The-Cowgirl-Position&id=4291843
http://ezinearticles.com/?5-of-the-Easiest-Karma-Sutra-Positions&id=4291334
http://ezinearticles.com/?Kama-Sutra-Positions—Doggy-Style&id=4284151
http://ezinearticles.com/?Extreme-Karma-Sutra-Positions-(Caution)&id=4297378
http://ezinearticles.com/?Karma-Sutra-Positions-For-Lesbians&id=4292086
Uploading Process:
- Easy to use interface with help being provided for everything that needs to be entered
- It automatically suggests keywords to use based on your article content
- Limited HTML allowed in content and author’s bio
Approval:
- Approval time happened from between 2-3 working days, even though they’re quoted as saying 7 days
- 1 article was asked to be reviewed because due to a pasting error there were too many HTML tags
Traffic:
- Total of 1467 articles views (about 293 per article)
- Total of 191 visitors to my website from the articles (about 38 per article)
- CTR of 7.6%
Average:
- About 5 visitors a day from each article
GoArticles – http://www.goarticles.com/
I have heard about GoArticles before, but have never used it. It’s ranked quite high in Google’s search index, so I thought I’d give this one a try.
Articles Uploaded:
http://www.goarticles.com/cgi-bin/showa.cgi?C=2890747
Uploading Process:
- Easy to use interface
- Automatic keyword suggestions based on your content
Approval:
- Article is approved and published immediately
Traffic:
- Total of 30 article views
- Traffic to website is 0
ArticlesBase – http://www.articlebase.com/
I think I’ve seen ArticlesBase twice in my life. It was when I was searching for specific information and I found 2 articles. I like the colors and the layout of the site. From what I gather, they have been around since 2005.
Articles Uploaded:
Uploading Process:
- Easy to use interface
- No automatic keyword suggestions
Approval:
- Article time for approval is quoted as 7 working days
- It took less than a day for my article to get approved
Traffic:
- The article was read 27 times
- Traffic to my website was 0
FreeArticles – http://www.freearticles.co.za/
Norio de Sousa used to own this site. Actually, he was the brainchild behind it, and it was a great success. It’s the only South African article directory I’ll ever turn to. 1 year ago it was sold to the new owner. I check back every now and then, but only to find what looks like a site that isn’t kept updated. The front page, which used to host featured articles, has just been blank every time I take a look. Even though there are problems, I decided to stay proudly SA, and at least use one South African site in this test.
Articles Uploaded:
Uploading Process:
- Easy to use interface
- No automatic keyword suggestions
Approval:
- There is no indication of how long it will take to get article approved
- After submitting, I was just presented with a blank page
- I logged into my account, to see that the article did indeed load
Update:
- Article still not approved
- No feedback from contact page on website
Outcome:
- I wasted about 2 hours of my life that I’ll never get back trying to get 1 article on this website
General Notes
This is by no means a scientific way of testing article directories, and I simply wrote about my experience with them. If you know of directories that have yielded better results for you, I’d like to hear about them!